White Shark
History Outdoor Travel

When Sharks and Surfers Collide

Story by Cheryl D. Wanner

Shark encounters are rare on the Oregon Coast, but they do happen.

Randy Weldon with his shark- bitten surfboard, 1983.
Randy Weldon with his shark- bitten surfboard, 1983.

April 22, 1998, was a perfect day for John Forse of Lincoln City to try out his new surfboard. Arriving at Gleneden Beach and finding blue skies, offshore winds, and a good swell, he spotted other surfers already in the water. But one of them—Randy Weldon, also of Lincoln City—called it quits shortly after Forse paddled out, saying he had a weird feeling. The others followed Weldon in, leaving Forse with the water all to himself.

From the corner of his eye, Forse saw a flash of movement. He attributed it to sea lions, but then something grabbed both his thigh and board in a sandwich grip and dragged him underwater. John saw the dorsal fin so close he could almost touch it and instinctively pounded on the back of what would later be estimated as an 18-foot white shark. He was released, but the shark still had the surfboard leash in its mouth, and when it dove down, Forse was dragged down with it. Unable to free his ankle from the strap, he figured this was the end. But the shark cut the leash with its teeth, and Forse shot to the surface and swam for his board, floating upside down on the surf. Once ashore, his friends gave him a lift to the hospital, where he was treated for a not-too-severe bite wound.

Closeup of Weldon's board.
Closeup of Weldon’s board.

Shark encounters are actually quite rare off the Oregon Coast. Only 28 incidents (all unprovoked and non-fatal) are listed in the Global Shark Attack File for Oregon, and most of these are surfboard bites, though a few involved bodily injury.

The white shark (Carcharodon carcharias) is responsible for all identified species incidents on the Oregon Coast. With its jaw thrust forward and the roof of its mouth and palate pulled back into a jagged-toothed maw, it can look like your worst nightmare. But far from the myth of Jaws, white sharks, aka “great whites,” are not mindless killing machines. They are social animals with a high level of intelligence and complex behavior. Inquisitive by nature, they just might decide to check out a pair of legs dangling from a surfboard or paddling through the water.    

John Forse surfing the Nelscott Reef.
John Forse surfing the Nelscott Reef.

Most human/white shark encounters resulting in injury are actually exploratory bites. “White sharks use their mouths like a hand; their teeth can feel and explore objects the way we use our fingertips,” says Mark Marks, research biologist, shark specialist, and founder of the Shark Protection and Preservation Association.  Bites typically occur because the shark is trying to get a handle on what it’s seeing.

When going for the kill, the white shark often shakes its head laterally, sawing back and forth with its teeth to dismember sea lions or seals or tear chunks of blubber from a whale. When merely exploring or taste testing, it will bite down and then let go, rarely coming back for a second hit. This sampling technique is consistent with most white shark/human interactions involving wounds or object bites, such as surfboards. Though there are recorded incidents of humans being consumed by sharks, such behavior is rare. Most fatalities result from tissue damage and blood loss due to the initial bite.

White shark bite on surfboard owned by Bobby Gumm.
White shark bite on surfboard owned by Bobby Gumm.

Of the many species of sharks found in Oregon’s coastal waters, only the white shark poses a threat to man. White sharks spend time offshore, but tend to patrol inshore when searching for prey. This sometimes brings them in contact with surfers.      

Randy Weldon, who’d felt something was amiss the day John Forse was bitten, came by his premonition naturally enough. Weldon, surfing a sandbar just south of Cape Kiwanda in 1983, had paddled out to catch the next wave set when something came up from below and bit his surfboard. The impact threw him several feet into the air. “I remember seeing the shark, but my mind wouldn’t accept it,” said Weldon, then 23. “I tried to figure out what was happening. Did someone paddle or surf into me? Did a sea lion hit me?” Surfacing and seeing a shark chomping on his board brought reality home. Weldon tried to paddle away, but his ankle was leashed to the board. The shark finally let go and headed west toward Haystack Rock. Stroking hard for shore, Weldon saw it coming back around from the south only to submerge just yards away and disappear. Shark experts believed it was a white with a length of 16 feet and a weight of 3,000 pounds.

Joseph Tanner measures  his healing shark bite
Joseph Tanner measures his healing shark bite

Most recently, Joseph Tanner, a critical care nurse at Emanuel Hospital in Portland, was severely bitten in the thigh and lower leg by a white shark off Indian Beach in Ecola State Park. In October 2016, Tanner was hanging vertically in the water, arms on his surfboard, when the shark grabbed his right leg from below and pulled him under. “My whole leg was in its mouth,” he said. “I thought I was going to die.” Tanner repeatedly punched the shark in the gills, and it let him go. He was able to grab his board and paddle ashore, rolling off into six inches of water where several people dragged him in. Tanner directed his own emergency procedures. He knew his blood type and told a bystander how to tie a tourniquet with his surfboard leash. He was airlifted to Emanuel (per his request) where he was hospitalized for nine days and underwent multiple surgeries. He bears the shark no ill will and has every intention of getting back into the water as soon as he is able.

White shark bite on surfboard owned by Bobby Gumm.
White shark bite on surfboard owned by Bobby Gumm.

Both John Forse and Randy Weldon are still actively surfing. Following his encounter in 1998, Forse explored the Nelscott Reef in Lincoln City and now hosts the Nelscott Big Surf Classic, which attracts surfers from around the world. These guys know the risks, but they also know the chance of a repeat encounter is extremely low. You’re much more likely to get hit by a car, struck by lightning, or meet up with any number of work-related or natural disasters than to be bitten by a shark.

Guadalupe White Shark.
Guadalupe White Shark.

And thanks to the work of shark biologists, a new picture is emerging of this apex predator we’ve feared for so long. Precautions are, of course, in order. But as knowledge replaces myth, perhaps we will have less fear and more respect for this creature in whose world we are merely a guest.

 

Story published in July/August 2017 print edition of Oregon Coast Magazine.